Blade qualification — NASA Rotor 67 (modelled as a Ti-6Al-4V blisk — alloy and attachment both ASSUMED, CADSF-1670; 22 blades, 34 vanes, 16042.8 rpm) — A TRANSONIC FAN ROTOR, NOT A TURBINE

22 blades · 16042.8 rpm · engine orders 1, 2, 34, 68 · ζ 0.002 · Ti-6Al-4V (as-received wrought, equiaxed alpha (~90 %) + residual beta (~10 %)) — NASA Rotor 67 benchmark · generated 2026-10-06T21:36:31.250Z · CADSF-1296

Assumption ledger — the inputs nobody measured

inputvaluerangestatusbasissafety factor over that range
material.tempC60 C20–100ASSUMEDNO DERATING IS APPLIED. The properties above are the pack's 20 C row, UNCHANGED, and every frequency and stress this run reports is therefore a 20 C number. The metal temperature is ASSUMED 60 C over 20-100 C on this basis: isentropic total-temperature rise computed from NASA TP-1493 TABLE I first-stage rotor pressure ratio 1.629 and the NACA standard-day inlet of NASA TP-2879 (288.2 K, 101 325 N/m^2): ideal rise 43.1 K, actual 48-51 K at 0.85-0.90 adiabatic efficiency, rotor-exit total 63-66 C; the 100 C upper end is the same arithmetic on an ISA+30 day (318.2 K inlet, exit total 99.8 C). The reason the assumption does not become a derating is stated in three places and agreed by all three: (1) sources.METAL_TEMPERATURE_C.note — the only E(T) figure available, Ti-6Al-4V losing ~3 % of E by 100 C from MIL-HDBK-5 Table 5.4.1.0(b), was NOT READ by CADSF-1543 and must not be re-quoted as though it were part of this basis; (2) the pack's own notApplicable.temperatureRange — "the chain must refuse a tempC it has no row for rather than interpolate to one"; (3) the pack carries one row, at 20 C, so there is nothing to interpolate between. WHAT THE BAND WOULD MOVE, IF THAT UNREAD FIGURE IS RIGHT: f ~ sqrt(E), so a 3 % modulus loss at the 100 C end is ~1.5 % on every frequency and every Campbell crossing speed, and Se for Ti-6Al-4V is reported insensitive below ~150 C so the Goodman arm barely moves. Both consequences are CITED, NOT READ, and are disclosed here rather than applied.not measured — the metal temperature moves Youngs modulus as well as Se, so it moves the mode shapes and the whole stress field with them. A band for it cannot be taken from this solve without pretending the stress field held still, so it is UNKNOWN here and belongs to a run at each end of the range.
rotor.excitation.magnitudePa5737 Pa2295–11474ASSUMEDNASA TM-87073 TABLE 2 measured wake depth 1-(Vcl/Uinf) = 0.126 (laser anemometer, 60 % span, 140 % chord, design speed) for this rotor, with the linearised gust relation dp/(0.5*rho*W^2) = 2*(dw/W), reduced for a DOWNSTREAM-stator potential field rather than a wake impingement because NASA TP-2879 records axial inflow and no inlet guide vane The fraction is applied to the rotor-inlet relative dynamic head 0.5*rho*W^2 = 114737 Pa, which is DERIVED in demos/benchmark_rotor67/sources.js INLET_STATION from published quantities only, with every step of the arithmetic on the page, and CROSS-CHECKED against a published number that was not used in it (computed relative tip Mach 1.397 against TM-87073's published 1.38, 1.3 %). CAVEAT, from sources.ENGINE_ORDERS: Rotor 67 in the TP-2879 campaign ran with NO stator at all. A 34 EO excitation is the STAGE configuration of TP-1493 / TM-87073, not the isolated-rotor configuration the laser anemometer data was taken in. The forced-response arm is therefore answering "what would this blade do in its stage", which is the right question for a certification and the wrong one to confuse with the LA measurements.0.0082–0.0409

These are ASSUMED inputs, not measurements of this machine. Each row names the basis it was chosen from and the range that basis supports; the last column is the verdict re-evaluated at both ends of that range. An assumed value never becomes a published one by being printed here. Replace a row with your own number and the band moves with it — that is what this table is for (ADR-20).

FAIL (SF 0.0082–0.0409) — INCOMPLETE — 2 of 3 checks answered

PDF: print this page (A4 page breaks and a print palette are built in).

The case

Operating speed16042.8 rpm
Sweep range0–17647 rpm
Sweep steps8
Blades N22
Sector angle16.364°
Engine orders1, 2, 34, 68
Damping ζ0.002
Axis[1,0,0] through [0,0,-96.375] mm
Excitationpressure-eo · 5.74 kPa on 12 face(s) · ASSUMED

Excitation amplitude basis — NASA TM-87073 TABLE 2 measured wake depth 1-(Vcl/Uinf) = 0.126 (laser anemometer, 60 % span, 140 % chord, design speed) for this rotor, with the linearised gust relation dp/(0.5*rho*W^2) = 2*(dw/W), reduced for a DOWNSTREAM-stator potential field rather than a wake impingement because NASA TP-2879 records axial inflow and no inlet guide vane The fraction is applied to the rotor-inlet relative dynamic head 0.5*rho*W^2 = 114737 Pa, which is DERIVED in demos/benchmark_rotor67/sources.js INLET_STATION from published quantities only, with every step of the arithmetic on the page, and CROSS-CHECKED against a published number that was not used in it (computed relative tip Mach 1.397 against TM-87073's published 1.38, 1.3 %). CAVEAT, from sources.ENGINE_ORDERS: Rotor 67 in the TP-2879 campaign ran with NO stator at all. A 34 EO excitation is the STAGE configuration of TP-1493 / TM-87073, not the isolated-rotor configuration the laser anemometer data was taken in. The forced-response arm is therefore answering "what would this blade do in its stage", which is the right question for a certification and the wrong one to confuse with the LA measurements.

Root restraintdistributed spring bed
Bed modulus5650 N/mm³ (tangential ×0.5)

DERIVED: k_n = E_Ti6Al4V(20 C) / t — DERIVED, not calibrated and not measured. THIS BODY MODELS ROTOR 67 AS A BLISK, WHICH IS AN ASSUMPTION: NASA published no attachment — neither TP-2879 nor TP-1493 names a dovetail, a disk, a platform or an integral rotor (re-read 2026-09-23, CADSF-1670; the ledger row is root.attachmentKnockdownPct). Within that premise this is NOT a joint stiffness — there is no joint in the model. It is a Winkler stand-in for the finite compliance of the disc rim the blade is modelled integral with, which the rigid-clamp control asserts is infinite. Nobody has measured it and no open source gives it. CADSF-1335's posture applies unchanged: the resonance verdict belongs over a stiffness SWEEP (--joint-stiffness), not at this one modulus, and the document says so wherever the verdict is printed. Source: /home/claude/r67/demos/turbine_blade/materials/ti-6al-4v.json#youngsModulusPa (PUBLISHED 113 GPa, Yin et al. 2025).

MaterialTi-6Al-4V (as-received wrought, equiaxed alpha (~90 %) + residual beta (~10 %)) — NASA Rotor 67 benchmark
Young's modulus113.0 GPa
Poisson's ratio0.31
Density4430 kg/m³
Yield Sy932.000 MPa
Ultimate Sut1027.000 MPa
Endurance Se540.000 MPa

fatigue corrections: size 0.873465 · surface 0.717977 · temperature 1 · reliability 0.753

source: demos/turbine_blade/materials/ti-6al-4v.json (ti-6al-4v-as-received), REUSED UNCHANGED. E 113 GPa / nu 0.31 / rho 4430 kg/m^3 (yin-2025-fod-ti64-blades); Sy 932 MPa, Sut 1027 MPa, Se 540 MPa (yuan-2024-vhcf-ti64).

The geometry this verdict rests on

Every number in this report was measured on a body and a mesh. This is that body and that mesh — the surface of the deck the solver actually ran, not a redrawing of the CAD. Drag to orbit, wheel to zoom, shift-drag to pan; the chips switch layers and only one viewer is ever live.

layersizewhat it is
Body7684 trianglesthe CAD tessellation the case was built from.
FE mesh23669 C3D1039993 nodes; 32408 surface triangles over 16204 vertices, wireframe over shaded.
Restraint2969 nodesroot restraint — grounded spring bed
Excitation4672 nodesexcitation patch — the faces the vane-wake pressure acts on
Dropped elementspresentdropped elements — tets outside the largest face-connected component
Mode shapes12 modesanimated at 16042.8 rpm; 528.9, 1201.5, 1647.6, 2584.1, 2916.9, 3336.7, 3959.9, 4717.1, 5186.6, 5292.2, 5634.4, 6470.3 Hz — the same frequencies the tables above carry.
Disk sectorabsentno disk sector in this run. not run — the case body is a single blade, not a disk sector. A SAFE diagram needs a cyclic-symmetry sector (rotor.cyclic {leftFaces, rightFaces}: one blade plus its slice of the disk, the two cut faces 360/bladeCount degrees apart) so CalculiX can solve the wheel one nodal diameter at a time. EO/nodal-diameter coincidence is therefore unchecked.

The viewer loads 4 sidecar files from viewer/ beside this document, on demand and never inlined: body.json 301 kB · mesh.json 718 kB · modes.json 1.49 MB · sets.json 84 kB — 2.56 MB in total. Keep that folder with this file, or the picture is the one thing that will not travel.

Modes at speed

phantom-mode guard: PASS — 0 of 16 mode(s) flagged as phantom, 0 negative eigenvalue(s), sliver fraction 0.19 % against a gate of 10 % (CADSB-919).

Frequencies at 16042.8 rpm, on the tangent stiffness left by the centrifugal static step. Normalisation mass.

modeHzrad/sparticipation x, y, z
1528.8563322.94.28e-3, 8.58e-3, 1.07e-3
21201.5277549.42.71e-3, -6.96e-3, -4.72e-4
31647.59710352.11.80e-3, -9.98e-4, 9.57e-4
42584.09816236.44.08e-3, -4.04e-3, -1.69e-3
52916.88818327.35.46e-4, 5.96e-4, 7.48e-4
63336.67320964.93.05e-3, -3.65e-4, 2.08e-4
73959.86324880.5-6.38e-3, 7.26e-4, 2.85e-3
84717.07629638.3-5.97e-3, -3.33e-3, 1.04e-3
95186.58132588.3-3.49e-4, 6.61e-4, -5.14e-4
105292.23433252.1-2.65e-4, -3.95e-4, 4.90e-4
115634.40535402.0-1.20e-3, -1.95e-3, 1.12e-4
126470.29540654.1-1.23e-3, -3.26e-3, -5.49e-4
136831.38442922.81.15e-3, -1.26e-3, 8.49e-4
147322.03646005.7-4.08e-4, -2.14e-3, -4.59e-4
158173.81851357.6-5.76e-4, 1.55e-3, 7.06e-5
168641.23654294.5-2.98e-4, 1.47e-3, 2.64e-4

Centrifugal stress from step 1 (von Mises peak)

peak von Mises1155.332 MPa
nodal peak von Mises1295.921 MPa
at22.85, -17.70, 60.94 mm
sourceintegration-point
centrifugal growth30.0963 mm

EALL, CENTRIF, 2.82239357e+6, 0,0,-96.375, 1,0,0

These are the UNSIGNED von Mises peak of the modal deck's static step (integration-point and nodal), maximised over every node — not the Goodman mean stress sigma_m, which is read at one node, at each crossing's own speed (Goodman panel). sigma_m 40.92 MPa is the signed MAJOR PRINCIPAL at node 12737; modal.prestress's 1295.92 MPa is the von Mises PEAK over every node — different scalars by design, 0.123x apart with the peak scaled by (8130.2 / 16042.8 rpm)^2 = 0.2568 to the crossing speed. sigma_1 at or below 2/sqrt 3 of the von Mises peak needs no particular stress state, so the pair is consistent (CADSB-1109).

Campbell diagram

CROSSING IN BAND — 2 crossing(s) inside +/-10 % of 16042.8 rpm: Mode 16 x EO 34 at 15088.7 rpm; Mode 1 x EO 2 at 15715.9 rpm

criterion: CONDITION 1 ONLY — 2 crossing(s) satisfy condition (1) inside +/-10 % of 16042.8 rpm. Condition (2) was NOT evaluated on this run, so the criterion is satisfied in one half and unmeasured in the other: the crossings stand, and this document exculpates nothing.

this Campbell diagram establishes CONDITION (1) of the CADSF-1340 / ADR-17 criterion — frequency coincidence — and nothing else. Condition (2), mode-shape coincidence, is measured by the generalised modal force and is reported in summary.criterion.condition2. A verdict quoted from this diagram alone is a statement about frequencies, not about resonance.

Why the band is not fully witnessed

16 mode(s) extracted per speed → 16 track(s) followed → 12 reported (clipped after tracking). 15 complete, 1 incomplete, 0 non-monotonic; 4 join(s) refused by the monotonicity gate; 4 eigenvalue(s) unattributed. Tracking metric: frequency continuity (no eigenvectors — MAC unavailable).

Modal-quality guards (ADR-14, corrected by ADR-15)

128 eigenvalue(s) solved across the sweep → 128 reached the tracker. 0 removed: 0 by the effective-mass filter (floor 1.0e-4 of the model total), 0 by the localisation check (restraint-artefact). 128 screened, 0 unscreened (kept, and UNKNOWN rather than passed).

Blade qualification — NASA Rotor 67 (modelled as a Ti-6Al-4V blisk — alloy and attachment both ASSUMED, CADSF-1670; 22 blades, 34 vanes, 16042.8 rpm) — A TRANSONIC FAN ROTOR, NOT A TURBINE — Campbell Blade qualification — NASA Rotor 67 (modelled as a Ti-6Al-4V blisk — alloy and attachment both ASSUMED, CADSF-1670; 22 blades, 34 vanes, 16042.8 rpm) — A TRANSONIC FAN ROTOR, NOT A TURBINE — Campbell 0 5000 10000 15000 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 Rotor speed (rpm) Frequency (Hz) EO 1 EO 2 EO 34 EO 68 idle 14438.5 rpm (operating band low edge (speedRpm - 10 %)): tightest margin Mode 15 x EO 34 -2 % Mode 3 leaves the extracted window at 7563 rpm — nothing is known about it above this speed Mode 1 x EO 68 at 327.6 rpm, 371.3 Hz Mode 1 x EO 34 at 656.3 rpm, 371.9 Hz Mode 2 x EO 68 at 876.3 rpm, 993.2 Hz Mode 3 x EO 68 at 1534.9 rpm, 1739.6 Hz Mode 2 x EO 34 at 1756.2 rpm, 995.2 Hz Mode 4 x EO 68 at 2023.6 rpm, 2293.4 Hz Mode 5 x EO 68 at 2486.8 rpm, 2818.4 Hz Mode 6 x EO 68 at 2904.4 rpm, 3291.6 Hz Mode 3 x EO 34 at 3071.5 rpm, 1740.5 Hz Mode 7 x EO 68 at 3224.6 rpm, 3654.5 Hz Mode 8 x EO 68 at 3997.4 rpm, 4530.4 Hz Mode 4 x EO 34 at 4069.8 rpm, 2306.2 Hz Mode 9 x EO 68 at 4211.7 rpm, 4773.2 Hz Mode 10 x EO 68 at 4404.2 rpm, 4991.4 Hz Mode 11 x EO 68 at 4858.8 rpm, 5506.6 Hz Mode 5 x EO 34 at 4976.6 rpm, 2820.1 Hz Mode 12 x EO 68 at 5393.9 rpm, 6113 Hz Mode 13 x EO 68 at 5802.3 rpm, 6575.9 Hz Mode 6 x EO 34 at 5809.2 rpm, 3291.9 Hz Mode 14 x EO 68 at 6192.3 rpm, 7017.9 Hz Mode 7 x EO 34 at 6489.1 rpm, 3677.1 Hz Mode 15 x EO 68 at 6818.5 rpm, 7727.6 Hz Mode 16 x EO 68 at 7180 rpm, 8137.3 Hz Mode 8 x EO 34 at 8130.2 rpm, 4607.1 Hz Mode 9 x EO 34 at 8389.5 rpm, 4754.1 Hz Mode 10 x EO 34 at 8853.4 rpm, 5016.9 Hz Mode 11 x EO 34 at 9685.1 rpm, 5488.2 Hz Mode 12 x EO 34 at 11005.9 rpm, 6236.7 Hz Mode 13 x EO 34 at 11712.8 rpm, 6637.2 Hz Mode 14 x EO 34 at 12626.1 rpm, 7154.8 Hz Mode 15 x EO 34 at 14108.2 rpm, 7994.6 Hz Mode 16 x EO 34 at 15088.7 rpm, 8550.3 Hz Mode 1 x EO 2 at 15715.9 rpm, 523.9 Hz Modes Mode 1 Mode 2 Mode 3 † Mode 4 Mode 5 Mode 6 Mode 7 Mode 8 Mode 9 Mode 10 Mode 11 Mode 12 Mode 13 ° Mode 14 ° Mode 15 ° Mode 16 ° 16043 rpm +/-10 % band crossing Tightest margin idle 14439 rpmoperating band low edge (speedRpm - 10 %) Mode 15 x EO 34 -2 % nom 16043 rpmspeedRpm Mode 1 x EO 2 -1.1 % max 17647 rpmoperating band high edge (speedRpm + 10 %) no margin evaluated ° tracked, outside the reported window † incomplete track 2 crossing(s) inside +/-10 % of 16042.8 rpm: Mode 16 x EO 34 at 15088.7 rpm; Mode 1 x EO 2 at 15715.9 rpm

Crossings

modeEOcrossing rpmHzmargin vs operating speedin bandtrackon the diagram
Mode 168327.6371.27-97.96 %nocompleteyes
Mode 134656.3371.92-95.91 %nocompleteyes
Mode 268876.3993.18-94.54 %nocompleteyes
Mode 3681534.91739.55-90.43 %noincompleteyes
Mode 2341756.2995.16-89.05 %nocompleteyes
Mode 4682023.62293.36-87.39 %nocompleteyes
Mode 5682486.82818.42-84.50 %nocompleteyes
Mode 6682904.43291.63-81.90 %nocompleteyes
Mode 3343071.51740.49-80.85 %noincompleteyes
Mode 7683224.63654.49-79.90 %nocompleteyes
Mode 8683997.44530.41-75.08 %nocompleteyes
Mode 4344069.82306.24-74.63 %nocompleteyes
Mode 9684211.74773.21-73.75 %nocompleteyes
Mode 10684404.24991.45-72.55 %nocompleteyes
Mode 11684858.85506.60-69.71 %nocompleteyes
Mode 5344976.62820.07-68.98 %nocompleteyes
Mode 12685393.96113.04-66.38 %nocompleteyes
Mode 13685802.36575.95-63.83 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 6345809.23291.86-63.79 %nocompleteyes
Mode 14686192.37017.93-61.40 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 7346489.13677.15-59.55 %nocompleteyes
Mode 15686818.57727.58-57.50 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 16687180.08137.32-55.24 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 8348130.24607.11-49.32 %nocompleteyes
Mode 9348389.54754.05-47.71 %nocompleteyes
Mode 10348853.45016.93-44.81 %nocompleteyes
Mode 11349685.15488.22-39.63 %nocompleteyes
Mode 123411005.96236.65-31.40 %nocompleteyes
Mode 133411712.86637.23-26.99 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 143412626.17154.77-21.30 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 153414108.27994.64-12.06 %nocompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 163415088.78550.29-5.95 %YEScompleteno — tracked, outside the reported window
Mode 1215715.9523.86-2.04 %YEScompleteyes

Extraction scope: INCOMPLETE — the extraction resolves to 8553.198 Hz inside the band and EO 34, 68 reach 19999.933333 Hz there: crossings of EO 34, 68 above 8553.198 Hz are UNKNOWN, not absent. Raising the ceiling is more eigenvalues per speed and nothing cleverer.

The sweep resolves modes to 8553.2 Hz inside the +/-10 % band, and EO 34 reaches 10000 Hz there, EO 68 reaches 20000 Hz there — above the ceiling nothing was extracted, so the band is clear of those orders only as far as the extraction goes.

Frequency margins at the operating point

modeEOmode HzEO Hzmargin≥ 10 %note
Mode 11529.11267.38+97.89 %yes
Mode 12529.11534.76-1.06 %NO
Mode 134529.119090.92-94.18 %yes
Mode 168529.1118181.84-97.09 %yes
Mode 211202.03267.38+349.56 %yes
Mode 221202.03534.76+124.78 %yes
Mode 2341202.039090.92-86.78 %yes
Mode 2681202.0318181.84-93.39 %yes
Mode 31—267.38—UNKNOWNMode 3 has no value at 16042.8 rpm: the track spans only 0..7563 rpm of the 0..17647 rpm sweep (4 of 8 speeds, 4 join(s) refused as non-monotonic) — extract more modes so the window keeps it
Mode 32—534.76—UNKNOWNMode 3 has no value at 16042.8 rpm: the track spans only 0..7563 rpm of the 0..17647 rpm sweep (4 of 8 speeds, 4 join(s) refused as non-monotonic) — extract more modes so the window keeps it
Mode 334—9090.92—UNKNOWNMode 3 has no value at 16042.8 rpm: the track spans only 0..7563 rpm of the 0..17647 rpm sweep (4 of 8 speeds, 4 join(s) refused as non-monotonic) — extract more modes so the window keeps it
Mode 368—18181.84—UNKNOWNMode 3 has no value at 16042.8 rpm: the track spans only 0..7563 rpm of the 0..17647 rpm sweep (4 of 8 speeds, 4 join(s) refused as non-monotonic) — extract more modes so the window keeps it
Mode 412585.93267.38+867.13 %yes
Mode 422585.93534.76+383.57 %yes
Mode 4342585.939090.92-71.55 %yes
Mode 4682585.9318181.84-85.78 %yes
Mode 512919.83267.38+992.02 %yes
Mode 522919.83534.76+446.01 %yes
Mode 5342919.839090.92-67.88 %yes
Mode 5682919.8318181.84-83.94 %yes
Mode 613336.58267.38+1147.88 %yes
Mode 623336.58534.76+523.94 %yes
Mode 6343336.589090.92-63.30 %yes
Mode 6683336.5818181.84-81.65 %yes
Mode 713964.04267.38+1382.55 %yes
Mode 723964.04534.76+641.27 %yes
Mode 7343964.049090.92-56.40 %yes
Mode 7683964.0418181.84-78.20 %yes
Mode 814721.61267.38+1665.88 %yes
Mode 824721.61534.76+782.94 %yes
Mode 8344721.619090.92-48.06 %yes
Mode 8684721.6118181.84-74.03 %yes
Mode 915319.54267.38+1889.50 %yes
Mode 925319.54534.76+894.75 %yes
Mode 9345319.549090.92-41.49 %yes
Mode 9685319.5418181.84-70.74 %yes
Mode 1015175.59267.38+1835.67 %yes
Mode 1025175.59534.76+867.83 %yes
Mode 10345175.599090.92-43.07 %yes
Mode 10685175.5918181.84-71.53 %yes
Mode 1115645.36267.38+2011.36 %yes
Mode 1125645.36534.76+955.68 %yes
Mode 11345645.369090.92-37.90 %yes
Mode 11685645.3618181.84-68.95 %yes
Mode 1216475.73267.38+2321.92 %yes
Mode 1226475.73534.76+1110.96 %yes
Mode 12346475.739090.92-28.77 %yes
Mode 12686475.7318181.84-64.38 %yes
Mode 1316839.95267.38+2458.14 %yes
Mode 1326839.95534.76+1179.07 %yes
Mode 13346839.959090.92-24.76 %yes
Mode 13686839.9518181.84-62.38 %yes
Mode 1417327.89267.38+2640.63 %yes
Mode 1427327.89534.76+1270.31 %yes
Mode 14347327.899090.92-19.39 %yes
Mode 14687327.8918181.84-59.70 %yes
Mode 1518186.92267.38+2961.91 %yes
Mode 1528186.92534.76+1430.95 %yes
Mode 15348186.929090.92-9.94 %NO
Mode 15688186.9218181.84-54.97 %yes
Mode 1618644.19267.38+3132.92 %yes
Mode 1628644.19534.76+1516.46 %yes
Mode 16348644.199090.92-4.91 %NO
Mode 16688644.1918181.84-52.46 %yes

Conventions

Spin softening (measured)

Spin softening IS in these frequencies: CalculiX has no card of that name, but the -Omega^2 M_perp term arrives through the deformation dependence of the CENTRIF body load, measured at 99.679 % of its analytical size (CADSF-1330). The residual non-conservative bias at 16042.8 rpm is therefore at most 0.217 Hz (0.0410 % of Mode 1), i.e. 3.8381 % of the tightest margin, taken at the worst-case gamma = 1.

residual bound 0.2169 Hz = 0.04099 % of Mode 1 = 3.83810 % of the tightest margin

Resonance across the joint-stiffness sweep

Pending — not_run. no joint-stiffness study accompanies this run, so the resonance verdict is quoted at one derived bed modulus only (tools/fea/blade_joint_stiffness.js runs the sweep).

SAFE diagram

not evaluated — single-blade model, no disk sector. not run — the case body is a single blade, not a disk sector. A SAFE diagram needs a cyclic-symmetry sector (rotor.cyclic {leftFaces, rightFaces}: one blade plus its slice of the disk, the two cut faces 360/bladeCount degrees apart) so CalculiX can solve the wheel one nodal diameter at a time. EO/nodal-diameter coincidence is therefore unchecked.

Dynamic (alternating) stress

peak alternating σa (tier B)15245.994 MPa
atnode 12737 · 4.03, 22.47, 121.41 mm
crossingmode 8 × EO 34 at 8130 rpm
Q842.29 (1/2ζ = 250)
modeEOrpmHzσa (forced response)Qpeak nodeerror
Mode 168327.6371.2720.426 MPa354.1113783
Mode 134656.3371.92283.056 MPa486.7913783
Mode 268876.3993.1882.403 MPa232.2913783
Mode 3681534.91739.55166.943 MPa380.441890
Mode 2341756.2995.16109.973 MPa210.8113783
Mode 4682023.62293.3636.369 MPa302.9813783
Mode 5682486.82818.4253.138 MPa369.469177
Mode 6682904.43291.6348.236 MPa391.651460
Mode 3343071.51740.491006.001 MPa540.921890
Mode 7683224.63654.4944.016 MPa353.8310370
Mode 8683997.44530.4192.204 MPa476.8112737
Mode 4344069.82306.24101.778 MPa342.2713783
Mode 9684211.74773.21110.340 MPa370.519029
Mode 10684404.24991.45111.929 MPa368.819029
Mode 11684858.85506.6065.650 MPa340.589025
Mode 5344976.62820.0774.649 MPa483.129177
Mode 12685393.96113.0467.411 MPa447.9412737
Mode 13685802.36575.952.704 MPa—9014
Mode 6345809.23291.86315.254 MPa527.221460
Mode 14686192.37017.931.040 MPa—9029
Mode 7346489.13677.1552.036 MPa418.9710370
Mode 15686818.57727.580.590 MPa—9029
Mode 16687180.08137.320.471 MPa—9029
Mode 8348130.24607.1115245.994 MPa842.2912737
Mode 9348389.54754.052947.590 MPa1319.8712737
Mode 10348853.45016.93169.015 MPa394.539029
Mode 11349685.15488.22156.806 MPa298.661016
Mode 123411005.96236.65114.817 MPa450.6112737
Mode 133411712.86637.2312.038 MPa—12737
Mode 143412626.17154.771.959 MPa—9029
Mode 153414108.27994.641.003 MPa—9029
Mode 163415088.78550.290.743 MPa—9029
Mode 1215715.9523.86104.637 MPa13.1413783

Goodman diagram and safety factor

criterionmodified-goodman
minimum SF0.016
required1.5
resultFAIL

REFUSED (CADSB-966 plausibility): this safety factor is NOT a measurement of the part — FAIL — 13 of 33 crossing(s) fall below the required safety factor 1.5; the worst is 0.016 at node 12737 on crossing 23 (mode 8, EO 34, 8130.2 rpm), with fatigue governing.

Governing point: sigma_m 40.923 MPa, sigma_a 15561.403 MPa at node 12737, 8130.2 rpm.

sigma_m 40.92 MPa is the signed MAJOR PRINCIPAL at node 12737; modal.prestress's 1295.92 MPa is the von Mises PEAK over every node — different scalars by design, 0.123x apart with the peak scaled by (8130.2 / 16042.8 rpm)^2 = 0.2568 to the crossing speed. sigma_1 at or below 2/sqrt 3 of the von Mises peak needs no particular stress state, so the pair is consistent (CADSB-1109).

Blade qualification — NASA Rotor 67 (modelled as a Ti-6Al-4V blisk — alloy and attachment both ASSUMED, CADSF-1670; 22 blades, 34 vanes, 16042.8 rpm) — A TRANSONIC FAN ROTOR, NOT A TURBINE — Goodman Blade qualification — NASA Rotor 67 (modelled as a Ti-6Al-4V blisk — alloy and attachment both ASSUMED, CADSF-1670; 22 blades, 34 vanes, 16042.8 rpm) — A TRANSONIC FAN ROTOR, NOT A TURBINE — Goodman Se' 255 MPa, Sut 1027 MPa, Sy 932 MPa. REFUSED (CADSB-966 plausibility): this safety factor is NOT a measurement of the part — FAIL — 13 of 33 crossing(s) fall below the required safety factor 1.5; the worst is 0.016 at node 12737 on crossing 23 (mode 8, EO 34, 8130.2 rpm), with fatigue governing. mode 1 x EO 68, 328 rpm — n 8.903 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 1 x EO 34, 656 rpm — n 0.645 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 400 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 2 x EO 68, 876 rpm — n 2.19 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 3 x EO 68, 1535 rpm — n 1.659 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 2 x EO 34, 1756 rpm — n 1.606 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 4 x EO 68, 2024 rpm — n 4.406 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 5 x EO 68, 2487 rpm — n 6.71 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 6 x EO 68, 2904 rpm — n 4.141 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 3 x EO 34, 3071 rpm — n 0.278 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 200 400 600 800 1000 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 7 x EO 68, 3225 rpm — n 5.325 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 8 x EO 68, 3997 rpm — n 2.57 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 4 x EO 34, 4070 rpm — n 1.497 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 9 x EO 68, 4212 rpm — n 2.905 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 10 x EO 68, 4404 rpm — n 2.854 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 11 x EO 68, 4859 rpm — n 5.29 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 5 x EO 34, 4977 rpm — n 4.281 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 12 x EO 68, 5394 rpm — n 2.606 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 13 x EO 68, 5802 rpm — n 4.223 PASS (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 6 x EO 34, 5809 rpm — n 0.657 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 400 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 14 x EO 68, 6192 rpm — n 3.727 PASS (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 7 x EO 34, 6489 rpm — n 2.562 PASS (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 15 x EO 68, 6818 rpm — n 3.076 PASS (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 16 x EO 68, 7180 rpm — n 2.775 PASS (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 8 x EO 34, 8130 rpm — n 0.016 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 5000 10000 15000 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 9 x EO 34, 8390 rpm — n 0.085 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 1000 2000 3000 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 10 x EO 34, 8853 rpm — n 1.2 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 11 x EO 34, 9685 rpm — n 1.505 PASS (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 12 x EO 34, 11006 rpm — n 1 FAIL (fatigue) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 13 x EO 34, 11713 rpm — n 1.036 FAIL (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 14 x EO 34, 12626 rpm — n 0.897 FAIL (yield) 0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 15 x EO 34, 14108 rpm — n 0.719 FAIL (yield) 0 500 1000 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 16 x EO 34, 15089 rpm — n 0.628 FAIL (yield) 0 500 1000 1500 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa mode 1 x EO 2, 15716 rpm — n 0.466 FAIL (fatigue) 0 500 1000 1500 0 100 200 300 Sut 1027 Sy 932 Se' 255 MPa Mean stress sigma_m (MPa, signed) across, alternating stress sigma_a (MPa, amplitude) up modified-goodman (n = 1) n = 1.5 node below the required factor
modeEOrpmHzmin SFat nodegoverningpass
168327.6371.278.90313783fatigueyes
134656.3371.920.64513783fatigueNO
268876.3993.182.19013783fatigueyes
3681534.91739.551.65912928fatigueyes
2341756.2995.161.60613783fatigueyes
4682023.62293.364.40613783fatigueyes
5682486.82818.426.710120fatigueyes
6682904.43291.634.14113783fatigueyes
3343071.51740.490.27812928fatigueNO
7683224.63654.495.32534772fatigueyes
8683997.44530.412.57013783fatigueyes
4344069.82306.241.49713783fatigueNO
9684211.74773.212.9051085fatigueyes
10684404.24991.452.8541085fatigueyes
11684858.85506.605.29013758fatigueyes
5344976.62820.074.28113783fatigueyes
12685393.96113.042.60612737fatigueyes
13685802.36575.954.22313783yieldyes
6345809.23291.860.65713783fatigueNO
14686192.37017.933.72713783yieldyes
7346489.13677.152.56234772fatigueyes
15686818.57727.583.07613783yieldyes
16687180.08137.322.77513783yieldyes
8348130.24607.110.01612737fatigueNO
9348389.54754.050.08512737fatigueNO
10348853.45016.931.20013783fatigueNO
11349685.15488.221.50513783yieldyes
123411005.96236.651.00013783fatigueNO
133411712.86637.231.03613783yieldNO
143412626.17154.770.89713783yieldNO
153414108.27994.640.71913783yieldNO
163415088.78550.290.62813783yieldNO
1215715.9523.860.46613783fatigueNO

Fatigue basis

Sut 1027.000 MPa · Sy 932.000 MPa · Se 540.000 MPa · Se corrected 255.003 MPa · material.enduranceLimitPa, as given

Spin softening IS applied by CalculiX and is measured, not assumed: there is no card of that name, but the -Omega^2 M_perp term arrives through the deformation dependence of the *DLOAD CENTRIF body load. CADSF-1330 measures it at 99.679 % of its analytical size (on-axis shaft f = sqrt(f0^2 - (rpm/60)^2) to 0.02 %; K_flap - K_lag = 0.99679 against a theoretical exactly 1 on the CADSF-1291 Southwell ladder), so the residual non-conservative bias on a crossing frequency is 0.32 % of gamma*(rpm/60)^2 in omega^2 — under 0.04 Hz on the showcase blade at 11 000 rpm. campbell.json summary.spinSoftening carries the per-case bound.,Tier A alternating stress is an upper bound on the PEAK and is not trustworthy node by node once a second mode is excited: CADSF-1294 measured Tier A 1.97x high at its own peak node on a C3D10 tet mesh. Quote Tier B where a Tier B run exists, and check altStressSource on each crossing below.,A single criterion is a single opinion. Gerber is a fit to mean data and runs less conservative than modified Goodman at mid mean stress; modified Goodman is the conventional design line and the default here.,A safety factor is per NODE of this mesh. It is not a life in cycles, it says nothing about crack growth, notch sensitivity beyond whatever k_surface was given, or the scatter the reliability factor is standing in for.

Disclosures — what this analysis does and does not model

Warnings from the run

Provenance

Solvercalculix 2.21
ElementC3D10 (order 2)
Nodes / elements39993 / 23669
Target element size3.9987 mm
Wall clock7115.42 s
Generated2026-10-06T21:36:31.250Z
stepranreasonwall s
modalyes161.4
campbellyes1043.56
rotordynamicsyes7.02
safenono_cyclic_sector0
dynamicyes5575.85
goodmanyes315

Body provenance (ADR-16 rule 5)

censusdemos/benchmark_rotor67/out/census.json
presentyes
kernel commitb53de206129255e31180d720b95ded0eb436f8d2
this checkout2c388f83d1cc6368feccbbfeccf55ff8956900fe

Artefacts

keyfile
casecase.json
qualificationqualification.json
deckcase.inp
resultsresults.json
campbell.jsoncampbell.json
campbell.svgcampbell.svg
campbell.mdcampbell.md
dynamic.jsondynamic.json
goodman.jsongoodman.json
goodman.fieldsgoodman_0.json,goodman_1.json,goodman_2.json,goodman_3.json,goodman_4.json,goodman_5.json,goodman_6.json,goodman_7.json,goodman_8.json,goodman_9.json,goodman_10.json,goodman_11.json,goodman_12.json,goodman_13.json,goodman_14.json,goodman_15.json,goodman_16.json,goodman_17.json,goodman_18.json,goodman_19.json,goodman_20.json,goodman_21.json,goodman_22.json,goodman_23.json,goodman_24.json,goodman_25.json,goodman_26.json,goodman_27.json,goodman_28.json,goodman_29.json,goodman_30.json,goodman_31.json,goodman_32.json
goodman.svggoodman.svg
goodman.mdgoodman.md

case directory: /home/claude/r67/tmp/rotor67-qual

NativeCAD blade qualification · CADSF-1296 · report v1 · solver calculix 2.21 · Campbell / SAFE / Goodman diagrams are NativeCAD post-processing over CalculiX solves; every number on this page came from a solver run or is marked pending.