Where the Andrews holds its soil: the stable zone, clearcuts and roads

Swanson and Dyrness split the Andrews into a stable zone of 33.4 km² on lava above a contact at 900 to 1,000 m, with only two small road slides from 1950 to 1974, and an unstable zone with 139 slides, where clearcuts lost 6,130 m³/km² to landslides, 2.8 times forest, and road rights of way 30 times. With the 2022-checked open slide inventory, the stable zone is 53.4% of the forest with the contact at 900 m and 44.9% at 1,000 m, against 52.0% published; it holds exactly 2 small road slides at 1,000 m and 5 at 900 m. Over the paper's own areas the clearcut rate comes out 6,356 m³/km² and the road rate 68,669; the forest rate comes out lower, so the ratios to forest come out higher than published.

How we did Matches except 1 of 18 exact, 5 within tolerance, 12 explained all studies
Swanson & Dyrness 1975: the two zones and their slides, with the contact at 1,000 m and at 900 m (the paper gives 900 to 1,000 m) · tolerance 2 percentage points for the zone share, whose line is drawn from a 1991 geology map and a DEM rather than the authors' field contact; exact for slide counts · Both lines are scored: 900 m matches the area, 1,000 m matches the two stable-zone road slides why
  • Stable zone, share of the forest, contact at 900 m (Table 1: 33.4 of 64.2 km²)52.0% → 53.39% +1.4 ptswithin tolerance
  • Stable zone, share of the forest, contact at 1,000 m52.0% → 44.88% −7.1 ptsexplained why
  • Road-related slides in the stable zone, 1,000 m2 slides → 2 slides 0match
  • Road-related slides in the stable zone, 900 m2 slides → 5 slides +3.0 slides (+150.0%)explained why
  • All slides in the stable zone, 1,000 m2 slides → 6 slides +4.0 slides (+200.0%)explained why
  • Slides in the unstable zone, 1,000 m139 slides → 134 slides −5.0 slides (−3.6%)explained why
Slide erosion 1950-1974 in the unstable zone (1,000 m) over the paper's own Table 1 areas: tests the slide volumes and counts only · tolerance 10% for the rates, which a single large slide moves by up to 15%; none for the ratios
  • Clearcut, over the paper's 7.9 km²6,130 m³/km² → 6,356 m³/km² +225.6 m³/km² (+3.7%)within tolerance
  • Road right of way, over the paper's 1.5 km²65,470 m³/km² → 68,669 m³/km² +3,198.9 m³/km² (+4.9%)within tolerance
  • Forest, over the paper's 21.4 km²2,180 m³/km² → 1,711 m³/km² −468.7 m³/km² (−21.5%)explained why
  • Clearcut as a multiple of forest2.8 × → 3.71 × +0.9 × (+32.6%)explained why
  • Road right of way as a multiple of forest30 × → 40.1 × +10.1 × (+33.8%)explained why
Slide erosion 1950-1974 in the unstable zone (1,000 m) over areas mapped here with a 20 m right of way: the independent version (900 m on the page) · tolerance 10% for the rates; none for the ratios; 10 percentage points for the roads' share, which the paper gives only as 'about equally'
  • Clearcut, over 7.96 km² mapped6,130 m³/km² → 6,311 m³/km² +181.2 m³/km² (+3.0%)within tolerance
  • Road right of way, over 1.78 km² mapped65,470 m³/km² → 57,774 m³/km² −7,696.4 m³/km² (−11.8%)explained why
  • Forest, over 25.37 km² mapped2,180 m³/km² → 1,444 m³/km² −736.3 m³/km² (−33.8%)explained why
  • Clearcut as a multiple of forest2.8 × → 4.37 × +1.6 × (+56.1%)explained why
  • Road right of way as a multiple of forest30 × → 40.0 × +10.0 × (+33.4%)explained why
  • Management (8% roads, 92% clearcut) as a multiple of forest5 × → 7.2 × +2.2 × (+44.5%)explained why
  • Roads' share of management erosion at 8% / 92% ('about equally', read as 50%)50.0% → 44.32% −5.7 ptswithin tolerance
53.4% / 44.9%of the forest is in the stable zone with the contact at 900 m / 1,000 m; published 52.0% (Table 1)
[18, 10, 2]
2 / 5small road slides in the stable zone, 1950–1974, by field start elevation at 1,000 m / 900 m; published two
[48, 60]
6,356 m³/km²clearcut slide erosion, unstable zone (1,000 m), over the paper's clearcut area; published 6,130
[56]
120 of 120steps replay identically in a fresh session

Numbers in brackets, like [14], are step numbers in this study's run.json: the NativeGIS call that returned the figure. NativeGIS 0.3.0, recorded 2026-10-31 15:17 UTC.

Map of the HJ Andrews over a hillshade with the stable zone shaded blue (darker above 1,000 m, lighter from 900 to 1,000 m) and the 1950-1974 landslides as dots coloured by land use: red road, orange clearcut, green forest
GE012 slides 1950–1974 (2022-checked Lookout Creek inventory) by land use at the origin: road (red), clearcut (orange), forest (green); circles in the unstable zone, squares in the stable zone by field start elevation at 1,000 m. Blue: on GE009 lava and at or above 1,000 m (dark) or 900 m (light) on the 8 m 3DEP DEM, with streams (HJ Andrews HF013), the forest boundary and a hillshade of the DEM. Rendered as SVG by gis_render in the recorded run; click to zoom.

Click or tap a map to open it full screen, then zoom and pan.

What was published

The full text is open on the HJ Andrews site (pub491). Its Table 1 covers 1950–1974. The unstable zone is 30.8 km²: forest 21.4 km² with 32 slide events and 46,600 m³, clearcut 7.9 km² with 36 events and 48,400 m³, and road right of way 1.5 km² with 71 events. That gives 2,180, 6,130 and 65,470 m³/km², or 1.0, 2.8 and 30 times forest. The stable zone is 33.4 km² (forest 28.7, clearcut 4.1, right of way 0.6 km²), so it is 52.0% of the 64.2 km² the table covers; it has no forest or clearcut events, and the text names only two small road-related slides there. The zone line follows the bedrock contact, which the paper places between 900 and 1,000 m. The abstract prints the clearcut rate as 6,030 m³/km², but Table 1 and the text both give 6,130 (48,400 / 7.9): 6,030 is a misprint, and an earlier version of this page quoted it. That version also derived a road rate of 64,600 m³/km² from the abstract (30 × 6,030 / 2.8); the paper prints 65,470. At 8 percent roads and 92 percent clearcut, roads and clearcuts contribute about equally, and management raised slide erosion about 5 times over forest.

Journal article (Geology, Geological Society of America)Swanson, F.J. & Dyrness, C.T. (1975). Impact of clear-cutting and road construction on soil erosion by landslides in the western Cascade Range, Oregon. Geology 3(7): 393–396.

Full text (HJ Andrews pub491, PDF) · Abstract (TRID record 40137, open) · Andrews Forest landslide bibliography (citation) · Journal article (GSA)

Published method. Slides were compiled from Dyrness (1967), Fredriksen's watershed observations, air photos of 1946, 1951, 1955, 1959, 1967 and 1972, storm memos, interviews and field checks; each slide's volume came from its measured scar and its date from those sources and tree rings. Logging and road history came from Willamette National Forest timber-sale records; where the right-of-way area was not given, it was estimated from road length at an assumed width of 20 m. The zone line follows the bedrock contact mapped by Swanson & James (1975).

The data and where it came from

All of it is open: downloaded without an account or a form.

DataWhereLicence
GE012 Lookout Creek landslide inventory (slide_inv_lookout.shp, NAD83 / UTM 10N), its locations and attributes checked and corrected in 2022: the inventories of Dyrness (INV = D), Swanson (S) and Wallenstein (W), 1953–2014, with YEAR (one year the inventory assigns), YEAR_OR (the original date text), LANDUSE_1 (land use at the origin: R road, C cut, F forest), VOLMETER (volume, m³) and INITELEV (field-recorded start elevation, feet)HJ Andrews LTER, 457 kB zip, no form or account
https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/ge01202.zip
CC BY 4.0 (EDI record for GE012)
GE009 geology of the Andrews (geology.shp, NAD83 / UTM 10N); the clastic units Ttc, Tmt and Tu as in R15, every other unit lavaHJ Andrews LTER, 205 kB zip, no form or account
https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/ge00901.zip
HJ Andrews data policy (CC BY, acknowledgement requested)
GI006 HJ Andrews Experimental Forest boundary (boundary83.shp)HJ Andrews LTER, zip, no form or account
https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/gi00601.zip
HJ Andrews data policy (CC BY, acknowledgement requested)
USGS 3DEP elevation, exported as an 8 m DEM (32-bit float GeoTIFF, NAD83 UTM zone 10N): the 900 m and 1,000 m zone lines, the elevation under each slide as a cross-check, and the maps' hillshadeUSGS National Map 3DEP elevation image service (exportImage), no form or account
https://elevation.nationalmap.gov/arcgis/rest/services/3DEPElevation/ImageServer
US federal data, public domain
Harvest sites: historical harvest units with the year of the overstory cut (OVRSTRY_YR). Land cover / land use service, layer 0, as GeoJSON in EPSG:4326Oregon State University / HJ Andrews open-data hub, anonymous REST query, fetched 2026-10-30
https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/HJ_Andrews_LCLU__2018/FeatureServer/0
HJ Andrews data policy (CC BY, acknowledgement requested)
HJA roads: the Andrews road network as re-digitised from the 2008 LiDAR DEM, with no construction dates. Base layers service, layer 6, as GeoJSON in EPSG:4326Oregon State University / HJ Andrews open-data hub, anonymous REST query, fetched 2026-10-30
https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/HJ_Andrews_Base_GIS_Layers__2018/FeatureServer/6
HJ Andrews data policy (CC BY, acknowledgement requested)
HJ Andrews stream network (HF013, hydro.shp), NAD83 UTM zone 10N; drawn on the maps onlyHJ Andrews LTER, zip, no form or account
https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/hf01301.zip
HJ Andrews data policy (CC BY, acknowledgement requested)

The input files the run read, pinned by checksum

File (relative to the data folder)Bytessha256
samples/hja-open/gi00601/x/boundary83.shp10,5400774de0a9ebd9693…
samples/hja-open/ge00901/x/geology.shp31,0408380a806b8970f0f…
samples/dem3dep/lookout_creek_26910_8m.tif11,930,186de869b30bf1a2161…
samples/hja-open/ge01202/x/slide_inv_lookout.shp5,22446175d3f25916f8b…
samples/goodman-2023/hub/harvest_sites.geojson635,270abfe5b7ef269f51d…
samples/goodman-2023/hub/roads.geojson727,6646c913bf70d2c68df…
samples/hja-open/hf01301/x/hydro.shp173,308263271acd998f7bd…

Full checksums are in run.json. Replay refuses an input whose checksum differs.

Method

  1. Zones as areas. Reclassify the 8 m DEM to the land at or above 1,000 m, polygonize it, clip it to the Andrews boundary and then to the GE009 lava units: that is the stable zone, and the unstable zone is the rest of the forest. Do the same at 900 m. The paper puts the contact between 900 and 1,000 m, so both lines are reported side by side.
  2. Slides. Clip the GE012 Lookout Creek points to the boundary and keep YEAR 1950–1974 (every original date text, YEAR_OR, of those slides lies wholly inside the period). Give each slide the rock unit under it (spatialJoin within GE009) and the DEM elevation under it. A slide is in the stable zone when its field-recorded start elevation (INITELEV, feet) is at or above the line (3,281 ft for 1,000 m, 2,953 ft for 900 m) and it is on lava; the DEM elevation is the cross-check. List each zone's slides by LANDUSE_1 with their volumes (VOLMETER); the page sums them.
  3. Land use by 1974 in the unstable zone, at each line: the hub harvest units with OVRSTRY_YR 1950–1974 (dissolved, so overlapping units count once), the road right of way as every hub road buffered 10 m each side (the paper's 20 m width), clearcut taken outside the right of way, and forest as the rest.
  4. Rates, two ways: each land use's slide volume over the paper's own Table 1 area (which tests only the slide volumes and counts), and over the area mapped here (the independent version).
  5. Render two maps as SVG over a hillshade of the DEM with the stable zone shaded at both lines; record the run and replay it in a fresh session.

The run made 120 NativeGIS calls: gis_open × 7, gis_process × 48, gis_query × 51, gis_close × 10, gis_render × 4.

Published numbers next to ours

The two zones and their slides, with the contact at 1,000 m and at 900 m

The paper puts the contact "between 900 and 1,000 m"; both lines are shown, and neither is chosen for its fit.

MeasurePublishedNativeGIS, 1,000 mNativeGIS, 900 mHow NativeGIS got it
Stable zone (above the line on lava), share of the forest52.0%
33.4 km² of 64.2 km²
44.9%
28.59 km²
53.4%
34.01 km²
DEM at or above the line, polygonized and clipped to the boundary (63.69 km²) [9, 17, 2], then to the GE009 lava units [5, 10, 18]; the unstable zone is the rest [11, 19]. At 1,000 m the stable zone is 5 separate pieces, the largest 28.44 km² [24, 25]
Slides 1950–1974 in the stable zone2, both small and road-related6
road 2, clearcut 0, forest 4
10
road 5, clearcut 1, forest 4
Field-recorded start elevation INITELEV (feet) at or above the line and the rock unit under the point on lava (spatialJoin within GE009) [37, 46, 58], listed by land use [48, 50, 52, 60, 62, 64]. At 1,000 m the road slides are 76 and 153 m³ and the forest slides start at 3,500–3,600 ft. By the DEM elevation under the point instead: 7 at 1,000 m [47], 10 at 900 m [59]. Slides at or above 1,000 m on the clastic units: 0 [70]
Slides 1950–1974 in the unstable zone139
road 71, clearcut 36, forest 32
134
road 69, clearcut 39, forest 26
130
road 66, clearcut 38, forest 26
140 slides of GE012 slide_inv_lookout with YEAR 1950–1974 inside the boundary [32] (Dyrness 44 [33], Swanson 96 [34]; all land uses: road 71, clearcut 39, forest 30 [43, 44, 45]), less the stable ones: below the line or on a clastic unit [54, 66]. 4 slides have INITELEV 0 (not recorded) and count as unstable; none of them is at or above 1,000 m on the DEM [36]

Rates with the paper's areas: tests the slide volumes and counts only

Land usePublishedNativeGIS, 1,000 mNativeGIS, 900 mHow NativeGIS got it
Clearcut6,130 m³/km²
2.8 × forest
6,356 m³/km²
3.71 × forest
6,065 m³/km²
3.54 × forest
39 slides, 50,209 m³ at 1,000 m [56]; 38, 47,915 m³ at 900 m [68]; over the paper's 7.9 km² (Table 1)
Road right of way65,470 m³/km²
30 × forest
68,669 m³/km²
40.1 × forest
68,057 m³/km²
39.8 × forest
69 slides, 103,003 m³ at 1,000 m [55]; 66, 102,086 m³ at 900 m [67]; over the paper's 1.5 km² (Table 1)
Forest2,180 m³/km²1,711 m³/km²1,711 m³/km²26 slides, 36,622 m³ at 1,000 m [57]; 26, 36,622 m³ at 900 m [69]; over the paper's 21.4 km² (Table 1)
Management at 8% roads, 92% clearcut, relative to forestabout 5 ×6.6 ×6.4 ×0.08 × road ratio + 0.92 × clearcut ratio
Roads' share of that management erosionabout equal48.4%49.4%0.08 × road rate against 0.92 × clearcut rate

Rates with areas mapped here, 20 m right of way: the independent version

Land usePublishedNativeGIS, 1,000 mNativeGIS, 900 mHow NativeGIS got it
Clearcut6,130 m³/km²
2.8 × forest
6,311 m³/km²
4.37 × forest
6,516 m³/km²
3.68 × forest
39 slides, 50,209 m³ at 1,000 m [56]; 38, 47,915 m³ at 900 m [68]; over 7.96 km² at 1,000 m [100] and 7.35 km² at 900 m [109] (paper 7.9 km²)
Road right of way65,470 m³/km²
30 × forest
57,774 m³/km²
40.0 × forest
61,182 m³/km²
34.5 × forest
69 slides, 103,003 m³ at 1,000 m [55]; 66, 102,086 m³ at 900 m [67]; over 1.78 km² at 1,000 m [97] and 1.67 km² at 900 m [106] (paper 1.5 km²)
Forest2,180 m³/km²1,444 m³/km²1,772 m³/km²26 slides, 36,622 m³ at 1,000 m [57]; 26, 36,622 m³ at 900 m [69]; over 25.37 km² at 1,000 m [104] and 20.67 km² at 900 m [113] (paper 21.4 km²)
Management at 8% roads, 92% clearcut, relative to forestabout 5 ×7.2 ×6.1 ×0.08 × road ratio + 0.92 × clearcut ratio
Roads' share of that management erosionabout equal44.3%44.9%0.08 × road rate against 0.92 × clearcut rate

Units: m³ from GE012 VOLMETER, m² in NAD83 / UTM zone 10N (EPSG:26910), reported as km². Slides are zoned by their field start elevation; areas by the DEM. Clearcut is the hub harvest units cut 1950–1974 (120 units [86]) outside the right of way; the right of way is every hub road buffered 10 m each side, the paper's 20 m width; forest is the rest of the unstable zone. Units with no recorded year cover 0.38 km² of the unstable zone [102] and count as forest. In the 1,000 m stable zone by 1974: 4.30 km² of clearcut [115] and 0.69 km² of right of way [116] (paper 4.1 km² and 0.6 km²). 183 GE012 points of all years lie in the forest [27].

Why any numbers differ

Replay it yourself

The run file records every call, its arguments, the checksums of the files it read and the numbers it returned. Replaying it repeats every call in a fresh NativeGIS session and checks that each answer comes out the same.

Verified reproducible on 2026-10-31: 120/120 steps identical. The run file was replayed in a fresh NativeGIS session (0.4.0 (source 3692d6e)) against a folder holding nothing but the public downloads below, fetched with these exact commands.
  1. Make an empty data folder and fetch the inputs into it exactly as below (bash; the folder layout is the one the run file expects):
    cd /path/to/an/empty/folder
    mkdir -p samples/hja-open/ge01202 && curl -fL -o samples/hja-open/ge01202/ge01202.zip https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/ge01202.zip && unzip -o samples/hja-open/ge01202/ge01202.zip -d samples/hja-open/ge01202/x
    mkdir -p samples/hja-open/ge00901 && curl -fL -o samples/hja-open/ge00901/ge00901.zip https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/ge00901.zip && unzip -o samples/hja-open/ge00901/ge00901.zip -d samples/hja-open/ge00901/x
    mkdir -p samples/hja-open/gi00601 && curl -fL -o samples/hja-open/gi00601/gi00601.zip https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/gi00601.zip && unzip -o samples/hja-open/gi00601/gi00601.zip -d samples/hja-open/gi00601/x
    mkdir -p samples/dem3dep && curl -fL -o samples/dem3dep/lookout_creek_26910_8m.tif 'https://elevation.nationalmap.gov/arcgis/rest/services/3DEPElevation/ImageServer/exportImage?bbox=558400,4891600,572400,4904600&bboxSR=26910&imageSR=26910&size=1750,1625&format=tiff&pixelType=F32&noData=-9999&interpolation=RSP_BilinearInterpolation&compression=None&f=image'
    mkdir -p samples/goodman-2023/hub && curl -fL -o samples/goodman-2023/hub/harvest_sites.geojson 'https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/HJ_Andrews_LCLU__2018/FeatureServer/0/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=geojson'
    mkdir -p samples/goodman-2023/hub && curl -fL -o samples/goodman-2023/hub/roads.geojson 'https://services1.arcgis.com/CD5mKowwN6nIaqd8/arcgis/rest/services/HJ_Andrews_Base_GIS_Layers__2018/FeatureServer/6/query?where=1%3D1&outFields=*&outSR=4326&f=geojson'
    mkdir -p samples/hja-open/hf01301 && curl -fL -o samples/hja-open/hf01301/hf01301.zip https://andrewsforest.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/lter/data/studies/spatialdata/hf01301.zip && unzip -o samples/hja-open/hf01301/hf01301.zip -d samples/hja-open/hf01301/x
  2. Download run.json (224,685 bytes, sha256 3c6c1164b09abafe28fa612a20424a56d6d188e312de69ee1a937b2faf040516).
  3. Ask your assistant to replay it with NativeGIS, or call the tool directly:
gis_replay {"action": "replay",
            "file": "<absolute path to the run.json you downloaded>",
            "inputRoot": "<your data folder>",
            "outputRoot": "<a new, empty folder>"}

Paths in the run file are relative to the data folder (inputRoot), and outputs go under outputRoot, so nothing depends on where the original run lived.

Files

Limits

NativeGIS reproductions · every NativeGIS number on this page is read from the recorded run file it links to.