R8 · HJ Andrews fire history (1532–1952) against 2023 Lookout Fire severity Confirmed
HJ Andrews fire-history map (DF019) sits up to about 200 m south of the forest
- Where
- HJ Andrews dataset DF019, firehistory_region.shp (knb-lter-and.3990.5).
- Published
- Fire-history polygons in NAD83 UTM zone 10N, converted from NAD27 in 2009 according to the file's processing history.
- What the data gives
- Along their shared ridgelines the layer's outer edge sits about 200 m south of both the HJ Andrews boundary and the 2018 LiDAR-based Lookout watershed, which agree with each other to 11 m. Registered on streams and summits only, Teensma's own 1987 maps put his study-area outline within about one registration error of the boundary, and DF019 182.6 m south of it on Lookout Ridge. At the north edge the two agree. The gap grows about 20.8 m per km southward, so DF019 is stretched about 2% north to south, not shifted; a NAD27/NAD83 mislabel would be a uniform shift with an east–west part. The 2004 preview already shows DF019 157.2 m south of the boundary, before the 2009 datum conversion. The most likely source is the 1997 step in which the episodes were "manuscripted onto HJA base maps and digitized".
- Suggested correction
- Re-register DF019 to Teensma's base maps (a north–south scale of about 0.979 about northing 4,903 km matches them), or note the offset in the metadata. The R8 study tests its result at three uniform offsets.
Found by rerunning the open data with NativeGIS. We have not contacted the authors or data providers yet. Full detail and the replayable run →
R8 · HJ Andrews fire history (1532–1952) against 2023 Lookout Fire severity Likely
A study-area outline stored as a fire
- Where
- DF019 metadata: "AGE = 0 means that a fire occurred in the polygon".
- Published
- One AGE = 0 polygon with EPISODE 1482, spanning the whole reconstruction area.
- What the data gives
- Its stair-stepped edge traces the study area, not a burn: it covers all of the forest but 71 ha. Treated as a fire, it makes every cell look burned at least once since 1482.
- Suggested correction
- Mark the 1482 polygon as the reconstruction's base or study area, not a fire episode.
Found by rerunning the open data with NativeGIS. We have not contacted the authors or data providers yet. Full detail and the replayable run →
R1 · MTBS Lookout Fire 2023 burn-severity acreage Confirmed
MTBS thresholds published without saying which side a boundary value falls
- Where
- MTBS fire bundles for the Lookout (2023) and Holiday Farm (2020) fires: perimeter attributes IncGreen_T, Low_T, Mod_T, High_T.
- Published
- The four dNBR thresholds for each fire, with no rule for values exactly on a threshold.
- What the data gives
- Re-deriving the class map with the usual rule (a value on a threshold goes up) disagrees in 0.38% of cells; putting it in the lower class reproduces the published map exactly, for both fires.
- Suggested correction
- State in the metadata that a dNBR value equal to a threshold belongs to the lower class.
Found by rerunning the open data with NativeGIS. We have not contacted the authors or data providers yet. Full detail and the replayable run →